Every week, millions of people toss plastic items into recycling bins with good intentions, only to have those items rejected at sorting facilities. The reality strikes hard: not all plastics are created equal, and understanding which types can’t be recycled saves time, reduces contamination, and helps the environment more than wishful recycling ever could.
The plastic industry uses seven resin identification codes (those numbers inside the triangle symbol), but only some actually make it through the recycling process. While codes 1, 2, and 5 typically get recycled in most communities, the others often end up in landfills despite appearing recyclable. Even more confusing, certain plastics that technically could be recycled lack the infrastructure or economic incentive to make it happen.
This breakdown reveals exactly which plastics cannot be recycled, why recycling facilities reject them, and what alternatives exist for responsible disposal.
The Non-Recyclable Seven
Plastic #3: Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC)
PVC stands as one of the most problematic plastics in circulation. Found in plumbing pipes, window frames, vinyl siding, and some food packaging, this material contains chlorine additives that release toxic chemicals when heated during recycling.
Most facilities refuse PVC because:
- Chlorine contaminates other plastic batches
- Processing releases harmful dioxins
- The rigid and flexible forms require different handling
- Specialized recycling is expensive and rarely available
Common PVC products include credit cards, shower curtains, garden hoses, and blister packaging for pills. That recycling symbol doesn’t mean your local program accepts it—fewer than 1% of PVC products get recycled in North America.
Plastic #6: Polystyrene (PS)
Polystyrene appears in two forms: rigid plastic (like CD cases) and expanded foam (like takeout containers). Neither version fares well in conventional recycling streams.
The foam variety, commonly called Styrofoam (actually a Dow Chemical trademark), breaks into tiny pieces that contaminate machinery. Its lightweight composition means hauling it to recycling centers costs more than the recovered material is worth. A single truckload of foam cups weighs almost nothing but takes up enormous space.
Rigid polystyrene products—yogurt containers, plastic cutlery, packing peanuts—suffer similar fates. While technically recyclable, the economics don’t work. Less than 5% of polystyrene ever gets recycled globally.
Plastic #7: Other (Mixed or Layered Plastics)
The catch-all category ** includes everything that doesn’t fit codes 1–6. This group contains some of the most frustrating non-recyclables:
- Polycarbonate (water cooler bottles, some baby bottles)
- Bioplastics (compostable cups, plant-based packaging)
- Multi-layer plastics (chip bags, juice pouches, squeeze tubes)
Multi-layer plastics deserve special attention. These products combine different plastic types into one package—aluminum foil bonded to plastic film bonded to paper, for example. Separating these layers requires specialized equipment that doesn’t exist in standard facilities.
Bioplastics confuse consumers most. Despite being marketed as eco-friendly, items like PLA (polylactic acid) cups contaminate traditional recycling. They require industrial composting facilities that reach 140°F or higher, which most communities lack.
Beyond the Numbers: Other Non-Recyclables
Contaminated Plastics
A perfectly recyclable plastic becomes trash the moment it’s contaminated. Food residue, grease, or hazardous materials render plastics unusable in new products.
Pizza boxes coated in grease? Non-recyclable. Peanut butter jars with sticky residue still inside? Contaminated. Motor oil bottles that haven’t been thoroughly rinsed? Hazardous waste.
The 5% contamination rule applies at many facilities: if a batch of recyclables contains more than 5% contaminated materials, the entire batch goes to the landfill. Your unwashed yogurt container could doom a whole truck’s worth of otherwise good recyclables.
Black and Dark-Colored Plastics
Here’s something few people know: black plastic often can’t be recycled regardless of its resin code. Optical sorters at recycling facilities use infrared light to identify plastic types, but black pigments absorb this light instead of reflecting it.
Without proper identification, these items get rejected even when made from recyclable materials like HDPE or PP. Dark blue, brown, and red plastics sometimes face the same problem depending on the pigment concentration.
Thin Films and Bags
Plastic bags, shrink wrap, bubble wrap, and produce bags jam recycling machinery despite being made from recyclable HDPE or LDPE. These thin films wrap around sorting equipment gears, forcing facilities to shut down for manual removal.
Many grocery stores collect plastic bags separately for specialized recycling, but even these programs face challenges. Contamination rates for bag recycling exceed 25% because people include non-bags (chip bags, candy wrappers, degraded bags) in drop-off bins.
Small Plastic Items
Bottle caps, plastic straws, coffee pod lids, and other items smaller than 2–3 inches fall through sorting screens designed for larger containers. These pieces either contaminate glass recycling or end up in landfills.
Some facilities now accept caps when screwed onto bottles, as the combined size passes through screens. But loose caps, lids under 3 inches, and tiny plastic fragments remain non-recyclable in conventional systems.
The Truth About Symbols and Labels
Decoding the Chasing Arrows
The triangular recycling symbol doesn’t guarantee recyclability. It simply indicates the plastic resin type. Manufacturers include these symbols for identification, not as promises that recycling infrastructure exists.
This confusion leads to “wishful recycling”—tossing questionable items in the bin hoping they’ll get processed. This behavior increases contamination and actually reduces overall recycling rates by forcing facilities to discard entire batches.
“Recyclable” vs. “Accepted for Recycling”
Marketing claims add another layer of complexity. A package might say “100% recyclable” while your local program doesn’t accept it. The label means recycling is technically possible, not that facilities near you actually process that material.
Check your municipality’s specific guidelines rather than relying on package labels. What’s recyclable in San Francisco might be trash in rural Ohio.
Why These Plastics Can’t Be Recycled
| Barrier Type | Explanation | Affected Plastics |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | Processing costs exceed recovered material value | Polystyrene foam, black plastics, thin films |
| Technical | Machinery can’t handle the material | Plastic bags, small items, multi-layer packaging |
| Chemical | Toxic additives contaminate recycling streams | PVC, some polycarbonates |
| Infrastructure | Facilities don’t exist in most areas | Bioplastics, specialty resins |
| Contamination | Food/chemical residue makes reprocessing impossible | Unwashed containers, greasy packaging |
The Economics of Recycling
Recycling only works when demand for recycled material exceeds supply costs. Oil prices directly impact plastic recycling viability—when virgin plastic is cheap to produce, recycled plastic can’t compete.
China’s 2018 “National Sword” policy banned most plastic imports, revealing how dependent Western recycling was on overseas processing. Without cheap labor markets accepting contaminated bales, many plastics previously labeled “recyclable” now go straight to landfills.
Chemical Composition Challenges
Different plastics don’t mix. Melting PET (#1) and HDPE (#2) together creates a useless hybrid material. This is why optical sorting is critical—and why plastics that can’t be optically sorted (like black plastics) become non-recyclable.
Some plastics contain additives that make recycling dangerous or impossible:
- Flame retardants in electronics cases
- Plasticizers (like phthalates) in flexible packaging
- UV stabilizers in outdoor furniture
- Pigments that contaminate color-specific recycling
What to Do With Non-Recyclable Plastics
Reduction Strategies
The best solution is avoiding non-recyclable plastics entirely. Practical swaps include:
- Glass or stainless steel containers instead of plastic storage
- Reusable shopping bags instead of disposable plastic
- Bar shampoo instead of plastic bottles
- Bulk bin purchases instead of individually wrapped items
- Refill stations for cleaning products
Specialized Recycling Programs
Some manufacturers run take-back programs for products they produce:
- TerraCycle accepts hard-to-recycle items through free and paid programs
- Plastic film manufacturers operate store drop-off programs
- Electronics retailers recycle device plastics through certified facilities
- Beauty companies (like MAC, Lush) accept empty packaging for recycling
Proper Disposal
When recycling isn’t possible, proper trash disposal beats wishful recycling. Non-recyclables placed in recycling bins:
- Contaminate good recyclables
- Damage sorting machinery
- Increase processing costs
- Lower overall recycling rates
Some communities offer separate streams for certain plastics. Research your local waste management options to find specialty drop-offs, hazardous waste events, or alternative programs.
The Future of Plastic Recycling
Chemical Recycling Technologies
Advanced recycling (also called chemical recycling) breaks plastics down to molecular components, allowing mixed or contaminated plastics to be reprocessed. This technology shows promise for materials traditional mechanical recycling can’t handle.
However, critics point out that chemical recycling requires enormous energy inputs and still can’t handle all plastic types. The industry remains in development stages, with limited commercial facilities operational.
Design for Recyclability
Forward-thinking manufacturers now design products with end-of-life in mind. This includes:
- Using single plastic types instead of mixed materials
- Avoiding problematic additives and dyes
- Creating products that can be easily disassembled
- Labeling clearly with accurate recycling information
The Ellen MacArthur Foundation’s New Plastics Economy initiative pushes brands toward circular design principles where all packaging is either reusable, recyclable, or compostable.
Policy Changes
Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) laws make manufacturers financially responsible for end-of-life management. These policies incentivize designing recyclable products and funding recycling infrastructure.
Several U.S. states have passed or proposed EPR legislation for packaging. Maine and Oregon lead with comprehensive programs requiring producers to pay for recycling systems. As these laws spread, they should improve recycling access and reduce non-recyclable plastic production.
Key Takeaways
- Plastics #3 (PVC), #6 (polystyrene), and #7 (mixed) are generally non-recyclable in standard municipal programs due to toxic additives, economic barriers, or technical limitations
- The recycling symbol doesn’t guarantee acceptance—check your local facility’s specific guidelines rather than relying on package labels
- Contamination from food residue, grease, or improper sorting can render otherwise recyclable plastics useless and contaminate entire batches
- Black plastics, thin films, small items, and multi-layer packaging face technical barriers that prevent conventional recycling regardless of resin type
- Reduction and reuse beat recycling—avoiding non-recyclable plastics entirely through conscious purchasing creates more environmental impact than recycling efforts
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I recycle plastic bags in my curbside bin?
No, plastic bags jam sorting machinery and should never go in curbside recycling. Most grocery stores offer separate collection bins for plastic bags, shrink wrap, and produce bags. These materials go to specialized facilities that process plastic film separately from rigid containers.
Why can’t Styrofoam be recycled like other plastics?
Polystyrene foam is 95% air by volume, making transportation costs higher than the material’s recovery value. It also breaks into small pieces that contaminate machinery and other recyclables. While technically recyclable, fewer than 100 facilities in North America accept it due to economic impracticality.
What should I do with black plastic takeout containers?
Black plastic cannot be recycled in most facilities because optical sorters can’t identify it. Throw black plastic in the trash, or better yet, request clear containers from restaurants when ordering takeout. Some forward-thinking brands have switched to clear or naturally-colored recyclable alternatives.
Are compostable plastics better than regular plastic?
Not necessarily. Compostable plastics require industrial composting facilities that reach specific temperatures—they won’t break down in home compost or landfills. They also contaminate conventional plastic recycling when mixed in. Unless your community offers industrial composting pickup, compostable plastics offer no environmental advantage.
How can I tell if a plastic item is actually recyclable in my area?
Check your municipality’s waste management website for accepted materials lists. When in doubt, use the “When In Doubt, Throw It Out” rule—contaminating recycling bins causes more harm than sending questionable items to landfills. Many communities also offer recycling hotlines or apps that identify accepted items.
Why do recycling rules vary so much between cities?
Each municipality operates different equipment and sells to different markets, creating varied capabilities. A city with advanced optical sorters might accept plastics #3–7, while a town with basic sorting only processes #1 and #2. Local economics, population density, and available processing facilities all influence what each program can handle.
Can I recycle plastic if it still has food residue on it?
No—contaminated plastics ruin entire recycling batches. Rinse containers until water runs clear before recycling. Greasy or sticky residue requires more thorough cleaning. If you can’t remove all contamination (like peanut butter jar residue), the item goes in the trash. Clean recyclables are worth far more than contaminated ones.
Quick Navigation